Understanding Your Job Security: Guidance from an Employment Law Lawyer in New York
You received a termination notice yesterday with no explanation—just “your employment is being terminated effective immediately.” Like many workers, you assumed you had job security as long as you performed well, showed up on time, and followed company policies. The harsh reality is that New York follows “at-will” employment, meaning your employer can terminate you for almost any reason—or no reason at all. However, this doesn’t mean you’re completely powerless. While your employer can fire you for no reason, it cannot do so for an illegal reason, and understanding this distinction could be the difference between accepting an unfair dismissal and fighting for your rights. An employment law lawyer in New York can help you navigate these complex waters and determine whether your termination crossed legal boundaries.
Pro Tip: Document everything related to your termination, including the exact words used, any prior incidents, and witness names—this information becomes crucial if your firing was illegal.
Don’t let the complexities of at-will employment leave you feeling powerless. Contact Kessler Matura P.C. for guidance on navigating your rights and ensuring your termination was lawful. Call us at 631-499-9100 or contact us today to take the first step toward protecting your future.
The Reality of At-Will Employment vs. Your Legal Protections
At-will employment is often misunderstood by workers who believe it gives employers unlimited power to terminate. In New York, if you work in the private sector, your employer is not required to have good cause to fire you, and in many cases, you can be fired for a bad reason, or no reason at all. However, this broad power has important limitations that an employment law lawyer in New York regularly helps workers understand. While employers can terminate you for poor performance, personality conflicts, or business restructuring, they cannot fire you for illegal reasons such as discrimination, retaliation for filing complaints, or exercising your legal rights. Employment discrimination laws protect workers from termination based on race, sex, sexual orientation, religion, national origin, physical disability, and age, creating a significant exception to at-will employment rules.
Pro Tip: If you suspect your termination was discriminatory, file a complaint with the New York State Division of Human Rights within three years for acts occurring after February 15, 2024—the deadline was recently extended from one year.
Steps to Take When You Suspect Wrongful Termination
When you believe your termination violated the law despite New York’s at-will employment rules, acting quickly protects your rights and strengthens your case. The process typically unfolds over several months, and understanding each phase helps you make informed decisions about pursuing legal action. An employment law lawyer in New York can guide you through this timeline while ensuring you meet critical deadlines that could affect your ability to recover damages.
-
Immediate Documentation (First 48 hours): Gather termination paperwork, employee handbook, performance reviews, and write down exactly what happened and who was present during your termination meeting.
-
Legal Consultation (Within 2 weeks): Meet with an attorney to evaluate whether your termination falls under illegal discrimination, retaliation, or other protected categories that override at-will employment.
-
Filing Administrative Complaints (30-90 days): Submit claims with appropriate agencies—the Division of Human Rights for discrimination or the Department of Labor for wage violations—which often must be filed before pursuing lawsuits.
-
Investigation and Evidence Gathering (3-6 months): During the Division’s investigation process, it may compensate complainants who experienced discrimination, as it awarded more than $8 million in its 2024 fiscal year.
-
Resolution or Litigation (6-18 months): Cases may resolve through mediation, settlement negotiations, or proceed to court if necessary to secure justice.
How Kessler Matura P.C. Protects Workers’ Rights Despite At-Will Employment
Even in an at-will employment state, experienced legal counsel can identify violations many workers don’t recognize. At Kessler Matura P.C., we understand that while your employer can fire you for no reason, it cannot do so for an illegal reason, and we know how to distinguish between lawful and unlawful terminations. Our team regularly helps workers recognize when their firing violated federal laws like the Fair Labor Standards Act, which prohibits retaliation against employees who attempt to assert their minimum-wage and overtime rights under the Act, or when New York workforce protections have been ignored. We work with clients to document discrimination, gather evidence of retaliation, and pursue compensation through both administrative channels and civil litigation when employers cross legal boundaries.
Pro Tip: Keep records of any complaints you made about workplace violations, safety issues, or discrimination—retaliation for these protected activities is illegal even in at-will employment states.
Understanding New York’s Expanded Worker Protections
New York has recently strengthened worker protections, creating more exceptions to at-will employment than many workers realize. The New York State Human Rights Law now applies to all employers within New York State, even those with fewer than four employees, meaning virtually every worker has discrimination protections. An employment law lawyer in New York stays current with these evolving protections, including recent legislation that strengthened protections against discrimination and harassment, which went into effect in phases after it was signed on August 12, 2019. The law now protects victims of harassment in important new ways, stating that harassment is against the law whenever an individual is subjected to inferior terms, conditions or privileges of employment, and the harassment need not be severe or pervasive for the employer to be liable.
Recent Legislative Changes Expanding Protected Classes
New York continues expanding protected categories beyond traditional discrimination grounds. Recent legislative proposals would expand protected classes to include height and weight discrimination in employment opportunities, while another bill from 2019 expanded New York’s workplace discrimination and reasonable accomodation protections to survivors of domestic violence. These developments show that at-will employment is becoming increasingly limited as lawmakers recognize the need for greater worker protections in an evolving economy.
Pro Tip: Stay informed about new protected classes and expanded rights—what might not have been illegal last year could be prohibited under current New York employment laws.
Federal Protections That Override At-Will Employment
While New York follows at-will employment, federal laws create significant exceptions that protect workers nationwide. The Fair Labor Standards Act provides several protections for employees, including requiring covered employers to pay nonexempt employees at least the federal minimum wage for all hours worked and overtime pay of at least one and one-half times the regular rate for hours worked over 40 in a workweek. Beyond wage protections, the FLSA also regulates child labor, prohibits employers from taking employee tips, and requires employers to provide reasonable break time and a place for covered nursing employees to express breast milk at work. An employment law lawyer in New York can help you identify when federal laws have been violated, even if state at-will employment rules might otherwise allow your termination.
FLSA Anti-Retaliation Protections
One of the most critical federal protections for at-will employees is the FLSA’s anti-retaliation provisions. The FLSA requires covered employers to maintain certain records about their employees and prohibits retaliation against employees who attempt to assert their rights under the Act. If you were fired for complaining about unpaid overtime, minimum wage violations, or other FLSA issues, your termination was illegal regardless of New York’s at-will employment rules.
Pro Tip: Document any complaints you made about wage violations, unpaid breaks, or working conditions.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Can my employer in Melville fire me without warning under at-will employment?
Yes, New York’s at-will employment generally allows employers to terminate workers without advance notice or cause. However, employers cannot fire you for illegal reasons such as discrimination, retaliation for filing complaints, or exercising legal rights like taking protected leave.
2. What constitutes wrongful termination in New York despite at-will employment laws?
Wrongful termination occurs when firing violates specific laws, such as discrimination based on protected characteristics, retaliation for whistleblowing, or violations of employment contracts. An employment law lawyer in New York can evaluate whether your termination falls into these protected categories.
3. How long do I have to file a discrimination complaint after being fired?
For acts occurring on or after February 15, 2024, you have three years to file with the New York State Division of Human Rights. For acts before that date, the deadline was one year. You can also file directly in New York state court within three years of the discriminatory act.
4. Can I be fired for filing a workers’ compensation claim or reporting safety violations?
No, New York Labor Law Section 740 protects whistleblowers, and retaliation for filing workers’ compensation claims is illegal. These protections override at-will employment rules and can result in reinstatement and damages.
5. What should I do immediately after being terminated if I suspect it was illegal?
Document your termination, gather relevant employment records, and consult with an attorney promptly. File any required administrative complaints within deadlines, and preserve evidence that supports your claim of illegal termination.
Work with a Trusted Employment Law Lawyer
At-will employment can feel overwhelming when facing unexpected termination, but understanding your rights and exceptions to these rules empowers you to make informed decisions. A knowledgeable attorney can distinguish between lawful terminations and those that violate federal or state protections, helping you determine whether you have grounds for legal action. Experienced legal counsel ensures your rights are protected and fights for the compensation you deserve under New York employment laws, whether dealing with discrimination, retaliation, or wage violations.
Feeling uncertain about your job security under New York’s at-will employment laws? Let Kessler Matura P.C. guide you through the maze of legal protections and ensure your rights are upheld. Don’t hesitate to reach out at 631-499-9100 or contact us to take control of your employment future.
